East Texas Principal’s Arrest Reignites Corporal Punishment Debate

A recent event at Overton High School has brought the contentious topic of corporal punishment into the limelight once again.

According to the Texas Tribune, Principal Jeffery Hogg found himself under arrest after administering a paddling to a female student, an action that has intensified discussions on the place of such disciplinary measures in modern education.

Texas holds its position among the 17 U.S. states where corporal punishment, encompassing methods like paddling, hitting, and spanking, remains permissible in schools.

While state-wide approval exists, the decision largely falls upon individual school districts. For those parents uncomfortable with the idea, they have the right to exempt their child through a written directive.

Over the years, Texas has been a battleground for this debate.

A significant turn came a few years ago when the state allowed parents a say in whether their children should be subjected to such disciplinary actions.

Rep. Alma Allen took the discussion to the state legislature this year, proposing a total cessation of its use in public schools. Many educators and mental health experts resonate with her sentiment, pointing out the potential trauma and detrimental psychological effects on students.

Yet, a considerable faction, primarily Republicans, cite religious texts like the Bible to uphold the practice.

National trends show a decline in the adoption of corporal punishment. Data indicates a stark reduction in students subjected to this discipline between the 2013-14 and 2017-18 academic years.

Echoing this sentiment, Miguel Cardona, U.S. Secretary of Education, has urged schools to look beyond such punitive measures.

Enter your number to get our free mobile app

Colorado and Idaho have set precedents by outlawing the practice recently. In a parallel move, Senator Chris Murphy is advocating for a federal mandate to prohibit this punishment in federally funded institutions.

Digging deeper into the East Texas incident, visible bruises remained on the student for days post-paddling. Despite the legality and prior consent from the student's family, Hogg's arrest was deemed necessary.

The school district stands firm with Principal Hogg, emphasizing that he acted within their policy's boundaries. Though the specifics of the student's misdemeanor remain undisclosed, the third and final paddle strike was delivered amidst her evident distress.

Subsequent medical evaluations likened the student's injuries to child abuse.

This incident has stirred diverse opinions, with some parents rallying behind Hogg. Their argument hinges on the mother's presence during the paddling.

A concerning statistic from 2017-18 places Texas second only to Mississippi in corporal punishment instances. Several studies indicate the harmful nature of such practices, suggesting they neither benefit nor teach students any valuable lesson.

As this debate continues, there's anticipation that corporal punishment might find its way into discussions in Texas's next legislative session.